11.

Hood v. the United Kingdom
(No. 27267/95)
18 February 1999 [Grand Chamber]

independence of military officer before whom detainee brought
(Article 5 §§ 3 and 5)
[violation];
independence and impartiality of court martial
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

12.

Larkos v. Cyprus
(No. 29515/95)
18 February 1999 [Grand Chamber]

discriminatory treatment of tenants of State-owned accommodation
(Article 14 + Article 8)
[violation]

13.

Buscarini and Others v. San Marino
(No. 24645/94)
18 February 1999 [Grand Chamber]

obligation of Members of Parliament to swear an oath on the Gospels
(Article 9)
[violation]

14.

Papachelas v. Greece
(No. 31423/96)
25 March 1999 [Grand Chamber]

irrebuttable presumption of benefit accruing from expropriation
(Article 1 of Protocol No. 1)
[violation];
length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[no violation]

15.

Iatridis v. Greece
(No. 31107/96)
25 March 1999 [Grand Chamber]

refusal of authorities to return property to tenant after eviction order quashed
(Article 1 of Protocol No. 1)
[violation];
lack of effective remedy
(Article 13)
[violation]

16.

Musiał v. Poland
(No. 24557/94)
25 March 1999 [Grand Chamber]

length of time taken to decide on a request for release from psychiatric detention
(Article 5 § 4)
[violation]

17.

Nikolova v. Bulgaria
(No. 31195/96)
25 March 1999 [Grand Chamber]

role of investigator and prosecutor in ordering detention
(Article 5 § 3)
[violation];
scope of court review of lawfulness of detention
(Article 5 § 4)
[violation]

18.

Pélissier and Sassi v. France
(No. 25444/94)
25 March 1999 [Grand Chamber]

reclassification of charge by appeal court without giving defence a proper opportunity to submit arguments
(Article 6 § 3 (a) and (b))
[violation];
length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

19.

Lemoine v. France
(No. 26242/95)
1 April 1999 [Section IV]

length of administrative proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[no jurisdiction – reference out of time]

20.

Trome v. Spain
(No. 27781/95)
1 April 1999 [Section IV]

refusal to allow third party to intervene in civil proceedings which affect it
(Article 6 § 1)
[agreed solution]

21.

Chassagnou and Others v. France
(Nos. 25088/94, 28331/95, 28443/95)
29 April 1999 [Grand Chamber]

obligation of certain land-owners to join the local hunting association and allow hunting on their land
(Articles 11 and 14, and
Article 1 of Protocol No. 1)
[violation]

22.

Aquilina v. Malta
(No. 25642/94)
29 April 1999 [Grand Chamber]

detainee brought before judge without power to order release
(Article 5 § 3)
[violation]

23.

T.W. v. Malta
(No. 25644/94)
29 April 1999 [Grand Chamber]

detainee brought before judge without power to order release
(Article 5 § 3)
[violation]

24.

Antunes Tomás Rebocho v. Portugal
(No. 34562/97)
30 April 1999 [Section IV]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

25.

Ledonne v. Italy (no. 1)
(No. 35742/97)
12 May 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

26.

Saccomanno v. Italy
(No. 36719/97)
12 May 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

27.

Ledonne v. Italy (no. 2)
(No. 38414/97)
12 May 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

28.

Jaffredou v. France
(No. 39843/98)
19 May 1999 [Section III]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

29.

Bladet Tromsø and Stensaas
v. Norway
(No. 21980/93)
20 May 1999 [Grand Chamber] 

defamation – reproduction of non-public official report
(Article 10)
[violation]

30.

Rekvényi v. Hungary
(No. 25390/94)
20 May 1999 [Grand Chamber]

constitutional prohibition on police officers engaging in political activities and joining political parties
(Articles 10 and 11)
[no violation]

31.

Oğur v. Turkey
(No. 21594/93)
20 May 1999 [Grand Chamber]

shooting of night-watchman during military operation
(Article 2)
[violation]

32.

Caillot v. France
(No. 36932/97)
4 June 1999 [Section III]

length of administrative proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

33.

Nunes Violante v. Portugal
(No. 33953/96)
8 June 1999 [Section IV]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

34.

Zubani v. Italy
(No. 14025/88)
16 June 1999 [Grand Chamber]

[just satisfaction]

35.

Abdurrahim Incedursun v. the Netherlands
(No. 33124/96)
22 June 1999 [Grand Chamber]

threatened expulsion to Turkey
(Article 3)
[friendly settlement]

36.

M.K. v. France
(No. 30148/96)
22 June 1999 [Section I]

interference with prisoner’s correspondence
(Article 8)
[friendly settlement]

37.

Laureano Santos v. Portugal
(No. 34139/96)
23 June 1999 [Section IV]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

38.

Matter v. Slovakia
(No. 31534/96)
5 July 1999 [Section II]

length of proceedings relating to deprivation of legal capacity on mental health grounds
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation];
forcible psychiatric examination
(Article 8)
[no violation]

39.

S.N. v. Portugal
(No. 33289/96)
6 July 1999 [Section IV] 

length of criminal proceedings which the applicant had joined as a party seeking damages
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

40.

Millan I Tornes v. Andorra
(No. 35052/97)
6 July 1999 [Section I]

requirement to obtain authorisation of the prosecution service in order to lodge an empara appeal in criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[struck out – settlement between parties]

41.

Ceylan v. Turkey
(No. 23556/94)
8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

conviction for incitement to hostility and hatred
(Article 10)
[violation]

42.

Arslan v. Turkey
(No. 23462/94)
8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

conviction for making separatist propaganda
(Article 10)
[violation]

43.

Gerger v. Turkey
(No. 24919/94)
8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

conviction for making separatist propaganda
(Article 10)
[violation];
independence and impartiality of National Security Court
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

44.

Polat v. Turkey
(No. 23500/94)
8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

conviction for making separatist propaganda
(Article 10)
[violation]

45.

Karataş v. Turkey
(No. 23168/94)
8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

conviction for making separatist propaganda
(Article 10)
[violation];
independence and impartiality of National Security Court
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

46.

Erdoğdu and İnce v. Turkey
(Nos. 25067/94 and 25068/94)
8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

conviction for making separatist propaganda
(Article 10)
[violation]

47.

Başkaya and Okçuoğlu v. Turkey
(Nos. 23536/94 and 24408/94)
8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

conviction for making separatist propaganda
(Article 10)
[violation];
independence and impartiality of National Security Court
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation];
absence of clear legal basis for imposing sentence of imprisonment
(Article 7)
[violation]

48.

Okçuoğlu v. Turkey
(No. 24146/94)
8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber] 

conviction for making separatist propaganda
(Article 10)
[violation];
independence and impartiality of National Security Court
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

49.

Sürek and Özdemir v. Turkey
(Nos. 23927/94 and 24277/94)
8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber] 

conviction for making separatist propaganda
(Article 10)
[violation];
independence and impartiality of National Security Court
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

50.

Sürek v. Turkey (no. 1)
(No. 26682/95)
 8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

conviction for making separatist propaganda
(Article 10)
[violation];
independence and impartiality of National Security Court
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

51.

Sürek v. Turkey (no. 2)
(No. 24122/94)
8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

conviction for disclosing identity of officials responsible for combating terrorism
(Article 10)
[violation];
independence and impartiality of National Security Court
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

52.

Sürek v. Turkey (no. 3)
(No. 24735/94)
8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber] 

conviction for making separatist propaganda
(Article 10)
[violation];
independence and impartiality of National Security Court
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

53.

Sürek v. Turkey (no. 4)
(No. 24762/94)
8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber] 

conviction for making separatist propaganda
(Article 10)
[violation];
independence and impartiality of National Security Court
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

54.

Tanrıkulu v. Turkey
(No. 23763/94)
8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

effectiveness of investigation into killing by unidentified perpetrators
(Article 2)
[violation];
availability of effective remedy
(Article 13)
[violation];
alleged discrimination
(Article 14)
[no violation];
hindrance of exercise of right of petition
[failure to comply with obligations]

55.

Çakıcı v. Turkey
(No. 22479/93)
8 July 1999 [Grand Chamber] 

disappearance of applicant’s brother after being taken into custody
(Article 2)
[violation];
alleged torture during custody
(Article 3)
[violation];
right to liberty and security
(Article 5)
[violation];
availability of effective remedy
(Article 13)
[violation];
(Articles 14 and 18)
[no violation]

56.

ERI, Lda. v. Portugal
(No. 31823/96)
22 July 1999 [Section IV]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

57.

Scarth v. the United Kingdom
(No. 33745/96)
22 July 1999 [Section IV]

lack of public hearing in arbitration proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

58.

Santos v. Portugal
(No. 35586/97)
22 July 1999 [Section IV]

length of civil proceedings which the applicant had joined as a party seeking damages
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

59.

Caetano Baeta v. Portugal
(No. 36671/97)
22 July 1999 [Section IV]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

60.

Bottazzi v. Italy
(No. 34884/97)
28 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

61.

A.P. v. Italy
(No. 35265/97)
28 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

62.

Di Mauro v. Italy
(No. 34256/96)
28 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

63.

A.L.M. v. Italy
(No. 35284/97)
28 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[no jurisdiction – reference out of time]

64.

Ferrari v. Italy
(No. 33440/96)
28 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

65.

Immobiliare Saffi v. Italy
(No. 22774/93)
28 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

staggering of granting of police assistance to enforce eviction orders
(Article 1 of Protocol No. 1)
[violation];
prolonged non-enforcement of judicial decision and absence of possibility of court review of prefectoral decisions staggering granting of police assistance
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

66.

Selmouni v. France
(No. 25803/94)
28 July 1999 [Grand Chamber]

torture in police custody
(Article 3)
[violation];
length of criminal proceedings which the applicant had joined as a party seeking damages
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

67.

Douiyeb v. the Netherlands
(No. 31464/96)
4 August 1999 [Grand Chamber]

alleged unlawfulness of detention due to procedural error in custody order
(Article 5 § 1)
[no violation];
speedy review of lawfulness of detention
(Article 5 § 4)
[no violation]

68.

Bosio and Moretti v. Italy
(No. 36608/97)
6 September 1999 [Section II] 

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

69.

Bohunický v. Slovakia
(No. 36570/97)
13 September 1999 [Section II] 

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

70.

Buscemi v. Italy
(No. 29569/95)
16 September 1999 [Section II] 

child custody
(Article 8)
[no violation];
impartiality of judge
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

71.

Lustig-Prean and Beckett v. the United Kingdom
(Nos. 31417/96 and 32377/96)
27 September 1999 [Section III]

dismissal of homosexuals from the armed forces following investigation into private life
(Article 8)
[violation]

72.

Smith and Grady v. the United Kingdom
(Nos. 33985/96 and 33986/96)
27 September 1999 [Section III] 

dismissal of homosexuals from the armed forces following investigation into private life
(Article 8)
[violation];
degrading treatment
(Article 3)
[no violation];
availability of effective remedy
(Article 13)
[violation]

73.

Civet v. France
(No. 29340/95)
28 September 1999 [Grand Chamber]

length of detention on remand
(Article 5 § 3)
[preliminary objection allowed – non-exhaustion]

74.

Dalban v. Romania
(No. 28114/95)
28 September 1999 [Grand Chamber]

conviction for defamation
(Article 10)
[violation]

75.

Öztürk v. Turkey
(No. 22479/93)
28 September 1999 [Grand Chamber]

conviction for incitement to hatred and hostility
(Article 10)
[violation]

76.

Serre v. France
(No. 29718/96)
29 September 1999 [Section III]

lack of public hearing in professional disciplinary proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

77.

Moore and Gordon v. the United Kingdom
(Nos. 36529/97 and 37393/97)
29 September 1999 [Section III]

independence and impartiality of courts martial
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

78.

Smith and Ford v. the United Kingdom
(Nos. 37475/97 and 39036/97)
29 September 1999 [Section III]

independence and impartiality of courts martial
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

79.

Djaid v. France
(No. 38687/97)
29 September 1999 [Section III]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

80.

Conceição Gavina v. Portugal
(No. 33435/96)
5 October 1999 [Section IV]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

81.

Scaruffi v. Italy
(No. 33455/96)
5 October 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

82.

Bagedda and Delogu v. Italy
(No. 33992/96)
5 October 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

83.

Donsimoni v. France
(No. 36754/97)
5 October 1999 [Section III]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

84.

Pesoni v. Italy
(No. 39694/98)
5 October 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

85.

Mangiola v. Italy
(No. 40179/98)
5 October 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

86.

La Brocca and Others v. Italy
(Nos. 40293/98 and 40295/98)
5 October 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

87.

Francesca v. Italy
(No. 40665/98)
5 October 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

88.

Silvestri and Others v. Italy
(Nos. 41327/98, 41328/98, 41329/98 and 41560/98)
5 October 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

89.

Perks and Others v. the United Kingdom
(Nos. 25277/94, 25279/94, 25280/94, 25281/94, 25285/94, 28048/95, 28192/95 and 28456/95)
12 October 1999 [Section III]

detention for non-payment of community charge
(Article 5 § 1)
[no violation];
unavailability of legal aid for proceedings relating to non-payment of community charge
(Article 6 § 3 (c))
[violation]

90.

Riera Blume and Others v. Spain
(No. 37680/97)
14 October 1999 [Section IV]

holding of members of sect against their will in order to be "de-programmed"
(Article 5 § 1)
[violation]

91.

Humen v. Poland
(No. 26614/95)
15 October 1999 [Grand Chamber]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[no violation]

92.

G.S. v. Italy
(No. 34204/96)
19 October 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

93.

Gelli v. Italy
(No. 37752/97)
19 October 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

94.

Emmolo v. Italy
(No. 42500/98)
19 October 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

95.

Scandella v. Italy
(No. 43494/98)
19 October 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

96.

Macciocchi v. Italy
(No. 43584/98)
19 October 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

97.

Carrozza v. Italy
(No. 43598/98)
19 October 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

98.

Maini v. France
(No. 31808/96)
26 October 1999 [Section III]

length of criminal proceedings which the applicant had joined as a party seeking damages
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

99.

Franzil v. Italy
(No. 34214/96)
26 October 1999 [Section II] 

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

100.

Ceriello v. Italy
(No. 33620/97)
26 October 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

101.

Scalvini v. Italy
(No. 36621/97)
26 October 1999 [Section II] 

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

102.

Calor Sud v. Italy
(No. 36624/97)
26 October 1999 [Section II] 

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

103.

Varipati v. Greece
(No. 38459/97)
26 October 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation];
effect of length of proceedings on property rights
(Article 1 of Protocol No. 1)
[no violation]

104.

Ferrara and De Lorenzo v. Italy
(Nos. 40282/98 and 40283/98)
26 October 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

105.

Escoubet v. Belgium
(No. 26780/95)
28 October 1999 [Grand Chamber]

lack of access to court for review of temporary withdrawal of driving licence following accident
(Article 6 § 1)
[no violation – Article 6 not applicable]

106.

Zielinski and Pradal and Gonzalez and Others v. France
(No. 24846/94 and Nos. 34165/96 to 34173/96)
28 October 1999 [Grand Chamber]

passing of legislation affecting outcome of pending court proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation];
length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

107.

Brumărescu v. Romania
(No. 28342/95)
28 October 1999 [Grand Chamber]

annulment by Supreme Court of Justice of final and binding judgment ordering return of property previously nationalised
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation];
deprivation of property
(Article 1 of Protocol No. 1)
[violation]

108.

Wille v. Liechtenstein
(No. 28396/95)
28 October 1999 [Grand Chamber] 

statement of intention on the part of the Prince of Liechtenstein not to appoint the applicant to public office in the future on account of his views on certain constitutional issues
(Article 10)
[violation]

109.

Gatto v. Italy
(No. 34469/97)
2 November 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

110.

Iuliano v. Italy
(No. 35756/97)
2 November 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

111.

Rossi v. Italy
(No. 36148/97)
2 November 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

112.

Passadoro v. Italy
(No. 36740/97)
2 November 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

113.

G.M.N. v. Italy
(No. 37131/97)
2 November 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

114.

Vitale and Others v. Italy
(No. 37166/97)
2 November 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

115.

L.G. v. Italy
(No. 37188/97)
2 November 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

116.

Ali’ v. Italy
(No. 37484/97)
2 November 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

117.

Ghilino v. Italy
(No. 38116/97)
2 November 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

118.

Errigo v. Italy
(No. 39789/98)
2 November 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

119.

Osteo Deutschland GmbH v. Germany
(No. 26988/95)
3 November 1999 [Section IV]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[struck out]

120.

Špaček s.r.o. v. the Czech Republic
(No. 26449/95)
9 November 1999 [Section III]

accessibility of regulations modifying the manner of preparing business accounts
(Article 1 of Protocol No. 1)
[no violation]

121.

Aprile de Puoti v. Italy
(No. 32375/96)
9 November 1999 [Section II] 

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

122.

Crossland v. the United Kingdom
(No. 36120/97)
9 November 1999 [Section III] 

unavailability of widows’ allowance to widowers
(Article 14)
[friendly settlement]

123.

Debboub alias Husseini Ali v. France
(No. 37786/97)
9 November 1999 [Section III]

length of detention on remand
(Article 5 § 3)
[violation]

124.

Arnò v. Italy
(No. 38098/97)
9 November 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

125.

Bargagli v. Italy
(No. 38109/97)
9 November 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

126.

M.C. v. Italy
(No. 38478/97)
9 November 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

127.

Gozalvo v. France
(No. 38894/97)
9 November 1999 [Section III]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

128.

Gros v. France
(No. 43743/98)
9 November 1999 [Section III]

length of proceedings relating to employment
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

129.

E.P. v. Italy
(No. 31127/96)
16 November 1999 [Section II]

length of child care proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation];
taking of child into care
(Article 8)
[violation]

130.

Marques Gomes Galo v. Portugal
(No. 35592/97)
23 November 1999 [Section IV]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

131.

Galinho Carvalho Matos v. Portugal
(No. 35593/97)
23 November 1999 [Section IV]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

132.

Arvois v. France
(No. 38249/97)
23 November 1999 [Section III]

length of administrative proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

133.

Hashman and Harrup v. the United Kingdom
(No. 25594/94)
25 November 1999 [Grand Chamber]

binding over to be of good behaviour – conduct contra bonos mores
(Article 10)
[violation]

134.

Nilsen and Johnsen v. Norway
(No. 23118/93)
25 November 1999 [Grand Chamber]

statements struck down by court as being null and void
(Article 10)
[violation]

135.

Lughofer v. Austria
(No. 22811/93)
30 November 1999 [Section III]

lack of public hearing in proceedings relating to land consolidation
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

136.

Faulkner v. the United Kingdom
(No. 30308/96)
30 November 1999 [Section III]

unavailability of legal aid for civil proceedings in Guernsey
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

137.

Baghli v. France
(No. 34374/97)
30 November 1999 [Section III]

expulsion of foreign national after lengthy period of residence
(Article 8)
[no violation]

138.

Bouilly v. France
(No. 38952/97)
7 December 1999 [Section III]

length of administrative proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

139.

Pellegrin v. France
(No. 28541/95)
8 December 1999 [Grand Chamber]

length of proceedings relating to the non-renewal of a contract of employment by the Government
(Article 6 § 1)
[no violation – Article 6 not applicable]

140.

Freedom and Democracy Party (ÖZDEP) v. Turkey
(No. 23885/94)
8 December 1999 [Grand Chamber]

dissolution of political party
(Article 11)
[violation]

141.

De Blasiis v. Italy
(No. 33969/96)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

142.

Khalfaoui v. France
(No. 34791/97)
14 December 1999 [Section III]

dismissal of appeal on points of law as a result of appellant’s failure to surrender into custody prior to appeal hearing
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

143.

Penna v. Italy
(No. 35168/97)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

144.

Ferreira de Sousa and Costa Araújo v. Portugal
(No. 36257/97)
14 December 1999 [Section IV]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

145.

A.M. v. Italy
(No. 37019/97)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

absence of opportunity to question witnesses living abroad
(Article 6 § 3 (d))
[violation]

146.

Antonakopoulos, Vortsela and Antonakopoulou v. Greece
(No. 37098/97)
14 December 1999 [Section III]

refusal of authorities to implement final and binding court judgment
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation];
non-payment by State of sums due to applicants
(Article 1 of Protocol No. 1)
[violation]

147.

Marchetti v. Italy
(No. 37702/97)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

148.

Serif v. Greece
(No. 38178/97)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

conviction of Muslim religious leader for usurping functions of a minister of a "known religion"
(Article 9)
[violation]

149.

Ediltes S.N.C. v. Italy
(No. 40953/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

150.

Cittadini and Ruffini v. Italy
(No. 40955/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

151.

I. v. Italy
(No. 40957/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Art 6 § 1)
[violation]

152.

Cantacessi v. Italy
(No. 40959/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

153.

Cassetta v. Italy
(No. 40961/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

154.

Castelli v. Italy
(No. 40962/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

155.

Aiello v. Italy
(No. 40963/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

156.

R. v. Italy
(No. 40964/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

157.

P. v. Italy
(No. 40966/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

158.

Privitera v. Italy
(No. 40967/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

159.

Muso v. Italy
(No. 40969/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

160.

Di Rosa v. Italy
(No. 40970/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

161.

F. v. Italy
(No. 40971/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

162.

Masi v. Italy
(No. 40972/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

163.

Iadanza v. Italy
(No. 40973/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

164.

Ercolino and Ambrosino v. Italy
(No. 40976/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

165.

Mastroeni v. Italy
(No. 41041/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

166.

G.B.Z., L.Z. and S.Z. v. Italy
(No. 41603/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

167.

Iacopelli v. Italy
(No. 41832/98)
14 December 1999 [Section IV]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

168.

M.R. v. Italy
(No. 41892/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

169.

Lombardo v. Italy
(No. 42353/98)
14 December 1999 [Section II]

length of criminal proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[friendly settlement]

170.

T. v. the United Kingdom
(No. 24724/94)
16 December 1999 [Grand Chamber]

trial of children for murder in adult court
(Article 3)
[no violation];
detention of convicted child "at Her Majesty’s pleasure"
(Article 5 § 1 (a))
[no violation];
absence of review of continuing lawfulness of detention
(Article 5 § 4)
[violation];
effective participation of child in trial in adult court
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation];
fixing by Executive of minimum period of detention to be served within discretionary sentence
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

171.

V. v. the United Kingdom
(No. 24888/94)
16 December 1999 [Grand Chamber]

trial of children for murder in adult court
(Article 3)
[no violation];
detention of convicted child "at Her Majesty’s pleasure"
(Article 5 § 1 (a))
[no violation];
absence of review of continuing lawfulness of detention
(Article 5 § 4)
[violation];
effective participation of child in trial in adult court
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation];
fixing by Executive of minimum period of detention to be served within discretionary sentence
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

172.

Skoutaridou v. Turkey
(No. 16159/90)
17 December 1999 [Section I]

access to property in northern Cyprus
(Article 1 of Protocol No. 1)
[struck out]

173.

G.S. v. Austria
(No. 26297/95)
21 December 1999 [Section III]

length of proceedings relating to application for licence to run pharmacy
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

174.

W.R. v. Austria
(No. 26602/95)
21 December 1999 [Section III]

length of proceedings relating to disciplinary proceedings against a lawyer
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]

175.

Salgueiro da Silva Mouta v. Portugal
(No. 33290/96)
21 December 1999 [Section IV]

refusal to award custody to homosexual father
(Articles 8 and 14)
[violation]

176.

Demirtepe v. France
(No. 34821/97)
21 December 1999 [Section III]

opening of prisoner’s correspondence
(Article 8)
[violation]

177.

Freitas Lopes v. Portugal
(No.. 36325/97)
21 December 1999 [Section IV]

length of civil proceedings
(Article 6 § 1)
[violation]